Are index funds halal?
Conventional index funds fail (they hold banks, insurers, and other non-compliant stocks); sharia-screened index funds exist precisely to fix this and are broadly accepted.
Owning a fund means owning slices of its constituents. The S&P 500 includes conventional banks and insurers whose core business is riba — roughly a third of constituents fail screening — so SPY/VOO-style funds are impermissible for most scholars regardless of their virtues as products.
The screened equivalents track the same markets minus the failures: SPUS (S&P 500 Shariah), HLAL (FTSE USA Shariah), SPWO (global). You keep indexing's diversification and low maintenance; the cost is a higher expense ratio (0.45–0.65% vs ~0.03%) — the current price of screening.
The conditions that matter
- Use funds tracking a recognized shariah index (S&P Shariah, FTSE Shariah, DJIM)
- Purify dividends per the sponsor's published figures
Check your own portfolio
Penny categorizes everything you own — stocks screened live against AAOIFI-style rules with rule-by-rule screening during the free trial and subscription, asset classes tiered like this page, zakat and purification built in. No bank login.
Download Penny for iOSFAQ
Is VOO or VTI halal?
No — both hold non-compliant financials among others. SPUS is the screened S&P 500 analog; HLAL and SPWO cover broader and global universes.
Are the halal index funds' fees worth it?
That's the real trade-off: ~0.45% vs ~0.03% compounds meaningfully over decades. The alternative is holding individually screened stocks yourself — zero fund fee, but you carry the monitoring. Many split: ETF core, screened-stock satellite.
Related
Educational summary of commonly held scholarly positions — not a fatwa or financial advice. Where scholars differ, we say so; for a binding ruling on your situation, consult your scholar. See how Penny screens.